Skip to content
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Is My First Grader's Messy Writing Normal or Dysgraphia?

It is the classic parent dilemma: trusting the teacher's expertise vs. trusting your own gut. At 6.5 years old (mid-First Grade), the line between "developmentally appropriate struggles" and "early signs of Dysgraphia" is incredibly blurry. While you don't want to pathologize normal development, you also don't want to "wait to fail."

Here is how to evaluate the situation objectively without needing a degree in Special Education:

1. Reversals: The "Normal" vs. "Concern" Line First, take a deep breath about the letter reversals. It is developmentally normal for children to reverse letters (b/d, p/q) and numbers (3, 5, 7) until age 7 or even 8.

  • Normal: Writing "bog" instead of "dog" occasionally, but correcting it when asked.

  • Concern: Reversing letters in every instance, or reversing letters that are not typically confused (like reversing an 'h' or 't').

2. The Physical Mechanics (The Dysgraphia Check) Dysgraphia is often more about the physical act of writing than the look of the letters. Watch her while she writes:

  • The "Death Grip": Does she hold the pencil so tightly her knuckles turn white?

  • Pain/Fatigue: Does she shake her hand out or complain her hand hurts after only a few minutes?

  • Posture: Does she lay her whole body on the desk or contort her wrist strangely?

If the answer is yes, this is a red flag for a motor issue that requires Occupational Therapy (OT), regardless of her age.

3. "Progress" Must Be Visible The teacher says she is making progress. Trust, but verify.

  • The "Side-by-Side" Test: Ask the teacher to pull a writing sample from September and place it next to a sample from today.

  • The Verdict: If you see any improvement (better spacing, staying on the line more often, more words written), the teacher is likely correct that it is developmental. If the samples look identical, "progress" is a stall tactic, and you should request an evaluation.

4. Action Step: Request an OT Screening Since she already has a 504 plan, you do not need to jump straight to a full psychological evaluation. Email the school and request an "Occupational Therapy Screening" for handwriting and fine motor skills. This is a low-stakes way to get a professional set of eyes on her mechanics without opening a full IEP evaluation yet.

VillageED’s special education services page offers guidance for dysgraphia signs and requesting OT screenings: https://www.villageed.org/sped-services.